I will repost my rating system until everyone gets used to it.
I do a simple impression of the cigar what I liked or disliked and have a 5 point scale
1 dog rocket. This is a crappy cigar. Of course better than a machine rolled. But harsh. Fast and got burn. Bad flavor or no flavor.
2. Yard gar. This is a descent smoke but its okay to smoke it if your are working in the yard. Or don't have time to finish.
3. Good smoke. Better than a yard gar. Hate to not finish it.
4. Premiums. these are great smokes. You will want to take your time. Have it with friends really enjoy it. They will be in your top 25.
5. Super premiums. These are your top 5 cigars. They are well constructed. Burn well. Taste awesome.
Ok
I've selected my 4. Ashton VSG.
Truly a premium smoke. Full of flavor. Complex. I prefer the sorcerer and the wizard sizes. Smoking a sorcerer while I write the review. Hints of cedar. The slightest touch of sweetness from the sun grown wrapper. Clean even burn. Smooth like silk on the tongue but still so full flavored. If I didn't have a good crop of 5s already this would push for it. But the top is reserved for the very best. This stick is just tobacco goodness. Solid 4.
I do a simple impression of the cigar what I liked or disliked and have a 5 point scale
1 dog rocket. This is a crappy cigar. Of course better than a machine rolled. But harsh. Fast and got burn. Bad flavor or no flavor.
2. Yard gar. This is a descent smoke but its okay to smoke it if your are working in the yard. Or don't have time to finish.
3. Good smoke. Better than a yard gar. Hate to not finish it.
4. Premiums. these are great smokes. You will want to take your time. Have it with friends really enjoy it. They will be in your top 25.
5. Super premiums. These are your top 5 cigars. They are well constructed. Burn well. Taste awesome.
Ok
I've selected my 4. Ashton VSG.
Truly a premium smoke. Full of flavor. Complex. I prefer the sorcerer and the wizard sizes. Smoking a sorcerer while I write the review. Hints of cedar. The slightest touch of sweetness from the sun grown wrapper. Clean even burn. Smooth like silk on the tongue but still so full flavored. If I didn't have a good crop of 5s already this would push for it. But the top is reserved for the very best. This stick is just tobacco goodness. Solid 4.