Taylor vs. Fonseca 1977

[mosesbotbol]

On another forum I participate on there's an ongoing debate on which house is better; Fonseca or Taylor. Both are heralded and fantastic producers.

We decided to pit them against each other on vaulted vintages such as 1977. We also drank a 1985 Fonseca, which is still a baby and do not recommend drinking for another 10+ years. 3 people, 3 bottles of port- yummm!

Which one was better? One did score one point higher. Can't tell you which one, but it was close...

 

[chibnkr]

I have had both, and actually prefer the Fonseca. A wonderful port. In general, I tend to be a fan of the Grahm's house style (slightly sweeter), but in 1977 (IMHO), the Fonseca reigns supreme.

 

[raisin]

I have had both, and actually prefer the Fonseca. A wonderful port. In general, I tend to be a fan of the Grahm's house style (slightly sweeter), but in 1977 (IMHO), the Fonseca reigns supreme.

Marchioly much agree's...

 

[mosesbotbol]

In General I would say I prefer Fonseca to Taylor, but only slightly. Both are fantastic and every vintage they make is great at a minimum. No dry wine can have as many consecutive hits as Fonseca or Taylor.

I've done back to back Fonseca vs. Taylor tastings for vintages 1977, 1970, 1963, and 1955.