If you like Black Seal, another good one to try is Screech Rum from Newfoundland. (Yes, Newfoundland.)
It's a bit rougher than Black Seal, but not in a bad way. And it goes very well with cigars.
Geez man... Screech? I recall a funny review of the stuff (which I've drank many times btw)...
"Screech Rum may be from Newfoundland, but it tastes like Toronto with a Detroit chaser. And somehow...against all advice...we finished the bottle. Because once the cap comes off, you realize it should never go back on. It gets dumped in one of two places: your mouth or the sink.
Things Screech Rum doesn't mix with: Orange Juice, Cranberry, Miller High Life, Tomato Soup (no joke - we hoped it would kill the taste).
Things Screech Rum mixes with: Nausea, Exuberance, Anger, Melancholy, Regret and Nausea."
Guys... stay well away from this stuff :r