Benchmade by Ashton (Don Pepin)

ryansallee

ChestBeater
I picked one of these up on a Don Pepin Binge. This is a short and long filler cigar blended by Pepin; I've heard that the filler is composed of JJ and San Cristobal clippings, but I can't confirm if that's true. It's handmade in Pepin's Nicaraguan factory. Here's the review:

Size: 6x50
Wrapper: Sumatra (Not completely sure; this is a guess. All I know it's Nicaraguan)
Price $3.00

Construction: At first this cigar doesn't look well constructed as the foot is a bit soft. After a good look though, the cigar is well rolled. The wrapper is a dark chocolaty brown that's very smooth and lacks any prominent veins. To add, the cigar didn't tunnel or have any funky problems during a full-fledged thunder storm. 10/10

Burn: At times the cigar would burn very uneven after ashing, but the burn tended to correct itself after a few good draws on the cigar. 9/10

Flavor: Mmm... tasty is the first puff of the cigar. In the first third, I was given a mellow nutty flavor along with a sweet tobacco flavor that ends with a little bit of pepper. The second third retained the nutty flavor that morphed into a more toasted nut flavor; however, the cigar was sans the tobacco flavor and the pepper. It seemed to replace a jalapeño flavor with the pepper. Also, the cigar came to be a little bit lighter in body in the second third. The final third was great as the cigar provided me a more of the nutty flavor along with a drier tobacco flavor than the beginning of the cigar. Also the Pepin pepper reappeared with more intensity, and the cigar became more full bodied. 10/10

Overall 29/30

This is an amazing smoke for only $3.00. I couldn't believe that the cigar was this good for the price. I will definitely get a box of these soon. The fact that the cigar didn't have a problem with the thunderstorm was even more amazing. This is superb.
 
Any trouble with ash getting all over you? That is my biggest problem with most mixed fillers.
 
Nice review. :tu I was just bombed a couple of these things and am really looking forward to trying them once they rest in the humi a tad.
 
Nice review. I got one of these in a sampler and like it so much I ordered a box. Figured I couldn't go wrong for the price.
 
I had one Saturday night. I'm heading to the local tonight to pick up a box. A nice smoke at a ridiculously low price.
 
damnit, now i gotta go burn one of these in the garage since it's raining :ss :tu
 
I just came in from enjoying my first Benchmade and really enjoyed it. A lot of nutty/woody/outdoorsy flavors that were quite nice. It would have been a great cigar for sitting around a campfire/fire pit.
 
I too have been wanting to try these for some time but I keep seeing "cheap" when I see these and that usually goes with "yard cigar" but now you have my curiosity perked. Think I will pick one up next time I visit my local B&M. Nice review.
 
Had my first tonight. If I take away the fact it was $2.75 and just comment on the cigar, I thought it was very, very average at best. The last 3rd was by far better than the rest.

Now if I factor in the fact I could get a box for $60, it gets better.

Still, don't think I would buy a box now. Will still try at least one of each of the 3 other sizes, had the robusto and I think the B&M had it a little wet.

Worth a shot for sure.
 
Back
Top