That was my point. They have the option to choose what to stock, Cuban or not, and yet they carry mainly Cubans. I do not know how difficult it is be for a tobacconist outside the US to obtain NC stock for their store, but if it isn't too difficult, then apparently the market dictates that Cubans are in fact better. I can't say with any certainty however. Therefore, my entire point may not be valid anyways. :tu
This is not totally correct. Tobacconists outside of the US do not necessarily have the option what to stock. Here in Australia you will not find NC cigars branded with the Cuban names like the NC Montecristo's, Punch's, Cohiba etc. Why, because it is illegal, they are a breach of copy right and branding laws. You only get them here if you do what I do and buy them off the net. It is illegal for retailers to sell them, not to have them.
If at some point in the future the embargo is lifted and Cuban cigars become legal in the US again, then these laws could be enforced their and you may find these NC cigars being forced to change name to continue to sell.
I am no lawyer so I don't know the full ins and outs of it, but that is the basic nuts and bolts. The fact that there is an embargo has enabled these manufacturers, despite efforts by Cuba in court, to get away with it.
We have other NC cigars available here (CAO, Gurkha, Arturo Fuente (won't find Anejo, too expensive and limited supply I guess), Ashton, Aurora, Puros Indios, Avo, Carlos Torano just to name a few) but yes they have found it hard to break into the market. Why? Because reputation is everything and Cuban cigars have the reputation that they are the best and that is a tough thing to break. Whether it is correct or not is irrelevant, I have had many NC cigars that to me are just as good as a Cuban cigar but then I am willing to branch out and try different things.
Bottom line is, a retailer will continue to carry plenty of stock of what sells and less of a choice of what is difficult to push.
So back to the question, what is better? Like I have said, I have enjoyed many NC and Cubans. And I have had some really sh!t NCs and Cubans. I have had many Cubans cigars of a particular line that are so inconsistent and foul that I would never buy them again, Monte #2 is an example and that's a big call since it is so popular with many people. It is up to the individual, the moment and the cigar.