Does it have to be spanish cedar??

TEAK

Gorilla
I have a little humi project that I am working on and I am having trouble getting my hands on some Spanish cedar and I was wondering if it would make a difference if I just used regular cedar???
Home Depot has the sheets of cedar that you can use to line you closets that have an adhesive on one side and I was thinking about using them. Any ideas?
 
No, but the only other wood you can use is Mahoghany. Cedar, if I remember correctly, has both poor moisture absorbtion properties as well as an odor that is not good for your cigars. Mahoghany will hold moisture like spanish cedar, but it doesnt give the aroma that spanish cedar does.
 
doesn't have to be spanish cedar, but it CAN'T be "regular" (aromatic) cedar.
 
Here is a artical from www.humidor-guide.com. Good luck on your project.
Does it always have to be Spanish cedar?

Primarily three types of wood are used for the humidor’s interior lining:

  • Spanish cedar (by far the most popular)
  • American (or Canadian) red cedar
  • Honduran mahogany
Spanish cedar offers the following advantages (botanical term “cedrela odorata”):

  • Protection from tobacco worms - through the cedar’s special odoriferous quality
  • High humidity absorption capacity - this ensures that a stable climate will be maintained inside the humidor and mold is prevented
  • Supports the cigar aging process
  • Positive effect on the flavor of the cigars
Spanish cedar does not originate from Spain as one might assume but is generally imported from Brazil and other countries of South and Central America. In some individual cases resin may form on the surface of the wood (See also humidor is secreting/resin). The risk of resin formation can be substantially reduced by previously drying the wood carefully.

American red cedar is inferior to Spanish cedar in humidity absorption and it exudes a more intense aroma. Some humidor manufacturers use American cedar because it is less expensive and with this wood there is no danger of resin formation. Particularly when storing cigars for longer periods the cigars will adopt a strong woody flavor that is generally not desired.

Honduran mahogany has a humidity absorption rate comparable to that of Spanish cedar and at the same time has a less intense odor. Thus, unfortunately, the deterrent effect on worms and the desired flavoring of cigars is also not as good as with Spanish cedar.
The veneer of the interior wood should be untreated.

For long-term cigar storage those humidors should be preferred, which are lined with Spanish cedar. For cabinet humidors other woods with high humidity absorption capacity can also be used because in cabinet humidors the cigars are generally stored in their original Spanish cedar boxes. A tray made of Spanish cedar is recommendable for storing individual cigars in cabinet humidors.
All adorini humidors are made exclusively with an interior lining of Spanish cedar.
 
Simple Phillipine Luan (mahogany) plywood is an inexpensive substitute for Honduran Mahogany.
 
Use Bobarians link and get Spanish cedar, don't settle for 2nd best. I'm sure you don't settle for 2nd best cigars, so why do it for your humidor? Just my :2.
 
Use Bobarians link and get Spanish cedar, don't settle for 2nd best. I'm sure you don't settle for 2nd best cigars, so why do it for your humidor? Just my :2.

+1

Here in Seattle, there's a Woodcraft right next door to my fave B&M, Rain City Cigar.

And in the event you think those prices are too much, think again. I've been tracking cedrela prices the past three years. They never go down.
 
Spanish Cedar and Honduran Mahogany are fine, and very similar (Spanish Cedar is actually in the same family as Mahogany). Do NOT use North American Cedars, as they are typically in the Cypress or Juniper family, and will impart a nasty flavor to your cigars, unless you like cedar flavored cigars... humidor-guide.com's advice that American (or Canadian) red cedar is OK, is wrong IMO. I also disagree with their opinion that Honduran Mahogany is inferior to Spanish Cedar, because:
1. "Worms" are not a problem in any humidor I know of.
2. I don't want my humidor to "flavor" my cigars. They are already boxed in Spanish Cedar anyway, and will age just fine given proper humidity and temperature control.
 
There is only one other wood that I know of that works in place of Spanish Cedar that has not yet been listed. Davidoff humidors use a rare wood called Gamboon wood that retains its humidity from moment number one.
 
Does anyone have an opinion on using veneer? It seems to be the least expensive way to get Spanish Cedar. It's as thin as 1/40" but perhaps better than nothing? I've heard from multiple sources that in a cabinet humi the cedar trays and boxes are adequate so this could just be icing on the cake?
 
Back
Top