There are just to many great cigars on the market to narrow it down to one let alone a top 5. I go through times where I smoke more of one brand than the others. Right now my go to cigar is a Cabiguan. So I bought a box of them. Just seems to be the flavor I've craved lately the most. If given an ultimatum of having to pick just one cigar I would probably go crazier than I am now. That's why I love the huge selection at the B&M that I work at, always is giving me something new to try, because I have to be able to give the customer my honest assessment of my thoughts. That;s why it is such a tough gig.lol