Great sticks! And I'm sure you will enjoy them!
I must rain on your parade just a bit, I'm afraid. SHAME ON ME! Don't want to tarnish your cbid excitement... cbid rocks, and be excited about your first purchase! Hate to tell you, it is the first of many, and your wallet will be sore.
Now for some practical advice. The "rarer" cigars are a bit dicey on cbid, and often you may overpay. I agree with you that if it takes you two hours to find the deal, lol... and you want 'em... then just pay the extra $10! Padron Annis actually aren't too bad... but things like Anejos are simply waaaaaaay overpriced.
My advice is always check two places to get a good "actual retail" to figure out whether it is worth it on cbid. I always check Cigars International and Holts to figure out what they actually go for, then see if it is worth it to go with cbid. You'll find that sticks like Gurkhas and Vintage Patels can be had for an absolute bargain.
A note on the Annis: Holts usually does have 5 packs of the '64s at reasonable prices, even non-sale, and they have them all the time. Check those out if decide you want more of 'em!
OR, do the lazy thing (like I do!) and fire a post up out here... "Anyone know where to find a good deal on [x]?" We'll help ya out.