Most Consistent Premium Brands

What Cigar Brand is the Most Consistent in terms of Quality and Smokeability

  • Cohiba (DR)

    Votes: 4 5.2%

  • Padron 1964 Anniversario

    Votes: 56 72.7%

  • Perdomo Estate Selection

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Montechristo

    Votes: 11 14.3%

  • Oliva Master Blends

    Votes: 6 7.8%

  • Graycliff

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Total voters
    77
Yup....Fuentes......that's what I was going to vote for. (Until I saw they were absent!!! :confused: )

But out of the choices give, I'd say Montecristo myself. :)
 
This ought to get replies. I bet he purposely left out Fuente to get replies. AND WTF is red dot doing there? :BS

Good poll bud!
-Matt-
 
Based on this list, I vote Padron...

..What's interesting to me is that you have the Oliva Masterblends up there. I had a churchill recently that had the same metallic taste as the first one I smoked. And yet, this was after I had 2 that were some of the nicest domestics I've ever had. Just when I thought I'd either been a less experienced smoker or had gotten a dud my first time out, this latest Oliva hit me with the same dissapointment as the first. Sad, really. I was very enthusiastic about this cigar a month or so ago.

I also think Avos belong on the list. I can't think of a more consistent smoke than Avo: whether one likes them or not, each line demonstrates a consistent flavour prfile from one cigar to the next, and all have exquisite burns.
 
My vote goes to Arturo Fuente. Not only are they consistent, they always are quite good! That goes from everything from the Brevas (great every day smoke) to the Hemingway series.

:)
 
Partagas has my vote. Great Domestic and ISOM line. Haven't had a Partagas that I did not like. I've had more of the Domestic line but its still an outstanding brand.

YAY Partagas!
 
I'll narrow it down even further and nominate the Fuente Don Carlos line. I know what to expect every time and it is wonderful!

-Q
 
Since AF's or AVO's werent upt here I had to pick Padrons.

1. Fuente anything Fuente
2. AVO Xo Series
3. Padrons

All this talk I have to go smoke one now.
 
Quixote said:
I'll narrow it down even further and nominate the Fuente Don Carlos line. I know what to expect every time and it is wonderful!

-Q
Click to expand...

I agree 100%! Never had a problem of any kind with a Don Carlos.
 
Ive just smoked Padron Anniversary 1964 Series of the ones that were mentioned... so I voted for them... But the Arturo Fuentes (Hemingways mostly) that Ive smoked was also very consistent...
 
Padron Anny series all the way!! I've never had a bad one.
I've had plenty of good AND bad VSG's, Hemmi's ... I don't smoke other fuente stuff (don carlos,etc..) enough to give an opinion on those.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top