My biggest problem with most traditional 'Cigar ashtrays' are the long groove that your stogie is supposed to rest in between puffs...
My biggest complaint is that the moist area around the cap tends to pick up wandering ashes, fingerprints, other BOTL's spit, etc., as your 'gar gets shorter.
Now, enter the Stinky!!! Your precious stogie is not resting in some long grove, but is able to perch in one of the stirrups... With the Stinky, that nasty 'ash/fingerprint/spit' problem is mitigated, if not ELIMINATED
And, hey, at around $20, it will hold a TON of nubs and ash, is easy to clean up, will support 4 (mini-herf) smokers at once!
Argee 1000%