Puck vs Heartfelt beads?

[Nerachnia]

Any difference or are they essentially the same. Looking to dump the foam in a few humidors and replace them with beads or the equivalent. Anyone have any comparisons?

 

[ca21455]

Beads do a better job regulating the humidity. The foam worked ok for me during the winter when the humidity was low, but during the summer the foam did a poor job.

 

[Scimmia]

The Puck is RH Beads in a container. No difference.

 

[j6ppc]

If you want a drop-in replacement get the puck.

If money is an issue for you and/or you like to tinker then 1/2 lb of beads are a great way to go.

HOWTO Retrofit here

 

[RockyP]

beads

 

[RPB67]

If you want a drop-in replacement get the puck.

If money is an issue for you and/or you like to tinker then 1/2 lb of beads are a great way to go.

HOWTO Retrofit here

:tpd:

The puck is great.I use it in my travel humidor. Its good to go all the time.

Get the Puck !

 

[kheffelf]

I have the beads in my big humi and in the two coolerdors I have the bigger puck, so I like both of them.

 

[Stogiefanatic182]

Ive got half a pound of beads in my 100 count and its dead on 65%

 

[n2advnture]

The Puck is RH Beads in a container. No difference.

Yep. The Puck Humidifier utilizes the RH Beads. It's engineered for a smaller volume of space than the bulk RH Beads in a convenient container. :u

Hope this helps
Mark

 

[Airborne RU]

Same same.

Essentially its like asking what is better Sodium chloride or table salt.

The puck is very easy to work with, esp since I can just throw it in my travel humi when I need to.

I even like the bulk beads that come with the mesh bag, that is also very useful.

 

[rockyr]

I have both and both work perfectly. The Puck in a small humidor and the Heartfelt beads in my coolerdor. Mark and David both provide great service and products.

 

[mastershogun]

just ordered a pound at 65%