I just have a problem with their rating system in general. First you rate the cigar on a level that is rediculous, 25 points for flavor, 25 for smoking characteristics, 15 for appearance and construction. Okay, I have a hard enough time using a 25 point rating system for one catagory as it is, then on top of that, 35 points on overall impression, give me a break.
This makes the rating system extremely subjective. Either a cigar looks good or not, either it burns good or not, either it is constructed good or not. Then they run off and give the smoker a huge gap of 35 points to rate a cigar that they just smoked, how about another 18.3 points if the cigar pairs well with a beverage?
The rating system should be easy and straight foreward, I came up with my own rating sytem on my blog. Simple and straight foreward, know what is being smoked and why it was rated the way it was, my rating system makes sense to me. Either it is a good cigar or it was not and gives the reader an idea of what they may expect when they smoke a similar cigar.