Recommend your favorite $4-5 cigar

[tfar]

Since I am always looking for outstanding price/value relations what are your recommendations? (It is hard to use the stupid search engine for this kind of question, so I know this must have been answered a million times; links will do)

I hear the Vegas Gold is a really nice mild smoke with good construction.

I like the Robusto, Churchill, Panetela and Figurado/Torpedo/Pyramid format best.

Till

 

[Shaun Raney]

Punch Rothschild Maduro
El Rey Del Mundo Robusto
Punch Champion

 

[Ratters]

Oliva Series G maduro. Medium at best but full of great flavors and an incredible value.

 

[roarknumber1]

Sosa Wavell
Joya De Nicaragua Celebracion

 

[rawlic]

I don't know if it's my favorite, but you won't find one more consistent than a Fuente 858 Maduro. And it's damn tasty too! I just finished one.

-Chuck

 

[tchariya]

Romeo Y Julieta Cedro Deluxe #1 or #2
Gran Habana Crojo #5 Gran Coronas

 

[TripleF]

Rocky Patel Edge Missile
Oliva Serie G Cameroon or Maduro
Padron 3000
Torano Casa Torano (CT or Maduro) Robusto



Dang.......this is makin' me want another stick.....

 

[Aladdin Sane]

:tpdadron 3000Maduro!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Rocky Patel Edge Missile
Oliva Serie G Cameroon or Maduro
Padron 3000
Torano Casa Torano (CT or Maduro) Robusto



Dang.......this is makin' me want another stick.....

 

[rottenzombie]

Fuente Hemingway.

 

[SR Mike]

I do not have a favorite, but these are some that come to mind that I enjoy.

$4-5 range (box price):
Perdomo Habano - Fantastic
Perdomo Lot 23 - Really Good
artagas Spanish Rosado - Fantastic
artagas Black - Fantastic
Maxx by Alec Bradley - Really Good

$3-4 Range:
Perdomo Fresca's - Fantastic
Sol Cubano - Really Good
Cigar.com Cuban Classic - Really Good
Cusano P1 - Good CAO Tins (these are all good Brazilia, MX2, Criollo, etc) I am not a CAO fan either, but these are impressive- Fantastic

I am sure there are a lot more I am not thinking of.

 

[Boobar]

CAO Brazilia Gol!
Partagas Black Clasico
5-Vegas Series A Archetype
Carlos Torano Signature Collection Robusto
Onyx Reserve Robusto

These are my current top 5 favorites.

 

[Darrell]

Camacho Coyolar #1 Perfecto
Padron 2000 Maduro

 

[Bax]

I'll go with HDM Dark Sumatra or the Maria Mancini Robusto or Magic Mountain.

 

[pistol]

There are a bunch of good threads for inexpensive cigars, check them out!
Here's TXMatt's, http://www.clubstogie.com/vb/showthread.php?t=57242&highlight=matt+cheap, and here's AdamH's, http://www.clubstogie.com/vb/showthread.php?t=29252, enjoy! They both have updates throughout the thread, so make sure you check out the entirety of both threads!

 

[sikk50]

Oliva G's
Onyx Reserves

 

[oceanelect4]

also add my vote for rocky patel edge lite or oliva is great.

 

[Munkey]

I'll go with HDM Dark Sumatra or the Maria Mancini Robusto or Magic Mountain.

I'll vote for the HDM DS as well.

 

[ShaulWolf]

Padron 3000 Maduro ftw!
A. Fuente 858 Maduro
Carlos Torano Reserva Selecta Churchill
Romeo y Julieta Reserve Maduro Robusto

 

[wayner123]

In that range I few a few favs. But these cigars you can get almost anywhere:

Punch Rare Corojo
Partagas Black
Olvia serie G maduro
Padron 3000
RyJ reserva real
Fuente SG

 

[shilala]

Short Story, El Original.