Haven't had it go soggy per se, but the cigar definitely softens up usually with smoking.
Have you ever.... Had a cigar that was firm to the touch before lighting, and then while smoking it, the cigar became soggy/squishy? Is this due to overheating?
I'd agree, your prolly smoking a little too fast.
........also, excess slobber will make a cigar appear squishy :ss
So will peeing on them... so don't do that. :tu