I found an interesting thread on CA, started by "Tony Maduro". After a great deal of effort, he created a list of "must try" cigars that pretty much everyone outta have at least once. Blatently plagerized from the thread found here.
ACID
Any cigar that is 20 years old
Anything by Carlos Torano
Arturo Fuente Anejo
Arturo Fuente Between the Lines
Arturo Fuente Don Carlos
Arturo Fuente Hemingway (Any size)
Arturo Fuente Opus X
Arturo Fuente Sungrown
Ashton Aged Maduro
Ashton Heritage
Ashton VSG
Astral Talanga Valley Selection
AVO 77
AVO Classic
AVO Domaine
AVO Signature
AVO XO
Camacho Corojo
Camacho Diploma
Camacho Liberty
Camacho SLR
CAO Brazilia
CAO Cameroon
CAO Crillo (Any size)
CAO Extreme
CAO MX2
Casa Blanca Jeroboam
Cuba Aliados Maduro
Cuban Crafters
Cuesta Rey Centro Fino Sungrown
Davidoff Millennium
Diamond Crown Maximus
Diamond Crown Maximus
Drew Estates Natural Robusto
El Original (Natural and Maduro)
El Rey del Mundo Robusto, Robusto Larga Oscuro
El Rico Habano
Fonesca Vintage Lonsdale
Flor de A. Allones
Fuente Don Carlos
Gispert Churchill and Belicoso
Graycliff
Griffin Fuerte
Gurkha Class Regent
JR Ultimates (Especially the Cabinet Series)
Gurkha Louis XIII Crystal
H. Upmann Classic Cameroon
H. Upmann Vintage Cameroon
Helix Maduro
Hoyo de Monterrey Dark Knight
Hoyo de Monterrey Excalibur
Indian Tabac Super Fuerte Torpedo
J.L.Salazar
Joya de Nicaragua Antano 1970
Joya de Nicaragua Celebracion
La Aurora Preferidos (Platinum, Maduro and Cameroon)
La Flor Dominicana Chisel
La Flor Dominicana Double Ligero
La Flor Dominicana Ligero
La Flor Dominicana Limitado
La Gloria Cubana Wavell Maduro
La Gloria Cubana Serie R Maduro
La Gloria Cubana Trunk Show Selections (Any year)
La Perla Habana Blonde
La Perla Habana Maduro Toro
Macanudo Vintage 1997
Mayorga Maduro
Montecristo Afrique
Montecristo White Label
Montesino Sungrown
Nat Sherman Host (Any size)
Nat Sherman Metropolitan (Any size, Natural and Maduro)
Oliva "O" Bold (Natural and Maduro)
Oliva Maduro
Oliva Master Blends
Cubita Spanish Market Selection
Padillas of any wrapper type (Hybrid, Cameroon, etc)
Padron Anniversary Maduro 1926
Padron Anniversary Maduro 1964
Padron Anniversary Natural 1964
Padron Maduro "K" Series (Maduro)
Partagas Black Label
Partagas Spanish Rosado
Partagas Cifuentes
Perdomo The Cigar
Perdomo Edicion de Silvio
Perdomo La Tradicion Reserve X
Perdomo Reserve Cabinet Figurado
Perdomo2
Punch Champion
Punch Gran Puro
Punch Rare Curojo
Romeo y Julieta Reserve Maduro
Romeo y Julieta 1875 Bully
Romeo y Julieta Cedro Delux #2
Sancho Panza Double Maduro
Savinelli Robustos
Vegas de Tabacalera Esteli
Italicized items are ones I've either tried or have found members here to have liked. Anything that's been overlooked?
Scott"nooriginalidea"M
ACID
Any cigar that is 20 years old
Anything by Carlos Torano
Arturo Fuente Anejo
Arturo Fuente Between the Lines
Arturo Fuente Don Carlos
Arturo Fuente Hemingway (Any size)
Arturo Fuente Opus X
Arturo Fuente Sungrown
Ashton Aged Maduro
Ashton Heritage
Ashton VSG
Astral Talanga Valley Selection
AVO 77
AVO Classic
AVO Domaine
AVO Signature
AVO XO
Camacho Corojo
Camacho Diploma
Camacho Liberty
Camacho SLR
CAO Brazilia
CAO Cameroon
CAO Crillo (Any size)
CAO Extreme
CAO MX2
Casa Blanca Jeroboam
Cuba Aliados Maduro
Cuban Crafters
Cuesta Rey Centro Fino Sungrown
Davidoff Millennium
Diamond Crown Maximus
Diamond Crown Maximus
Drew Estates Natural Robusto
El Original (Natural and Maduro)
El Rey del Mundo Robusto, Robusto Larga Oscuro
El Rico Habano
Fonesca Vintage Lonsdale
Flor de A. Allones
Fuente Don Carlos
Gispert Churchill and Belicoso
Graycliff
Griffin Fuerte
Gurkha Class Regent
JR Ultimates (Especially the Cabinet Series)
Gurkha Louis XIII Crystal
H. Upmann Classic Cameroon
H. Upmann Vintage Cameroon
Helix Maduro
Hoyo de Monterrey Dark Knight
Hoyo de Monterrey Excalibur
Indian Tabac Super Fuerte Torpedo
J.L.Salazar
Joya de Nicaragua Antano 1970
Joya de Nicaragua Celebracion
La Aurora Preferidos (Platinum, Maduro and Cameroon)
La Flor Dominicana Chisel
La Flor Dominicana Double Ligero
La Flor Dominicana Ligero
La Flor Dominicana Limitado
La Gloria Cubana Wavell Maduro
La Gloria Cubana Serie R Maduro
La Gloria Cubana Trunk Show Selections (Any year)
La Perla Habana Blonde
La Perla Habana Maduro Toro
Macanudo Vintage 1997
Mayorga Maduro
Montecristo Afrique
Montecristo White Label
Montesino Sungrown
Nat Sherman Host (Any size)
Nat Sherman Metropolitan (Any size, Natural and Maduro)
Oliva "O" Bold (Natural and Maduro)
Oliva Maduro
Oliva Master Blends
Cubita Spanish Market Selection
Padillas of any wrapper type (Hybrid, Cameroon, etc)
Padron Anniversary Maduro 1926
Padron Anniversary Maduro 1964
Padron Anniversary Natural 1964
Padron Maduro "K" Series (Maduro)
Partagas Black Label
Partagas Spanish Rosado
Partagas Cifuentes
Perdomo The Cigar
Perdomo Edicion de Silvio
Perdomo La Tradicion Reserve X
Perdomo Reserve Cabinet Figurado
Perdomo2
Punch Champion
Punch Gran Puro
Punch Rare Curojo
Romeo y Julieta Reserve Maduro
Romeo y Julieta 1875 Bully
Romeo y Julieta Cedro Delux #2
Sancho Panza Double Maduro
Savinelli Robustos
Vegas de Tabacalera Esteli
Italicized items are ones I've either tried or have found members here to have liked. Anything that's been overlooked?
Scott"nooriginalidea"M