Really quite tough to decide... Among cigars where I've smoked the whole thing myself, I'd have to go with the Habanos 1994 from the humidor. Other top cigars include the '72 RYJ Clemenceau, Expecialidad 1996, Partagas 150 Robusto, and a few others. If we're also including PPP cigars or cigars I've only puffed on a few times...the 1492s, Punch Nectares, and Don Candidos all come to mind. But man, I wish I could find more of those 1994s...