So heres the challenge, I want to get two new boxes of cigars to put in my new cabinet humidor. I you only had 120 bucks what would you get?
OK, so how badly do you want "boxes" to put in your humidor? There are many great suggestions for you already. I'd pose another option.
Save the box purchase for something that you know is your absolute favorite, you're going to put 20-25 of one stick in your humidor. Is that what you want to do? I like to stockpile different cigars, because my tastes may not be the same from day to day.
With that in mind, I'd consider doing $120 of cigars, but do it in sampler packs. Cigar International has a bunch of those available. You can get multiple shapes of all sorts of brands - Gurkha, Romeo y Juliet, Rocky Patel, etc...
Here is their mega-sampler page:
http://www.cigarsinternational.com/catDisp.asp?cat=106&page=all
But, as you consider that, here's something to help along the finances. First, they do a daily deal that gets you free shipping on your entire order... Visit their home page:
http://www.cigarsinternational.com/ and on the right, near the top-center, you'll see the picture shown below. Click on it. The daily deal will pop up, usually 10 cigars, maybe even 20 cigars. Usually, the price near $2.00 a stick. Today's special is Macanudos, I'd pass.
Order the special, get your free shipping, put the snag on a couple samplers, and you can put between 40-60 cigars in your humidor.
Of course, if you want to do boxes, I am not sure that even the CI deal will beat the deal one brother suggested from Taboo. In fact, might have to check that out myself.
Just another idea to throw into the mix.
I hate it when CAD strikes.