Who's interested in a group tasting?

I don't think Mike has mailed the sticks...he came out to Las Vegas this past weekend for a vacation and brought with him the sticks for the tasting...They all are giving me a hard time as far as what they may be...and I know that there is at least one...actually all...that are really going to throw me threw a loop...
 
Hey guys, just got home a few hour ago from my Memorial Day weekend.

Update:
I have everyones address
I have all the bags loaded, I'll get the boxes packed tomorrow night, and they will go out this weekend with DC#s posted here.
After things get shipped, I will post a picture of the cigars in the tasting
I will post the first thread for reviews after everyone has their cigars - the thread will be "SSSS #1" - if people get ahead of the planned schedule, just save your reviews and wait for the threads please

For a reference, one of my postings from a blind tasting on another site:
Cigar #4
Aesthetics: Shinny maduro, measuring about 6x46 (estimate) with a box press. A couple areas on the wrapper and cap where it doesn’t look like a clean cut. Rating 7

Construction: Bit of a soft spot at the foot. Tried to use my large punch, but that made the entire cap come off the cigar, so I used the cutter to try to save it. Stiff draw prior to lighting, makes me think there might be problems. It does look like the moisture from my lips is beading up on the wrapper. Solid white ash that held together for about 1.5 inches. Lot of smoke given off by the cigar, and a very even burn. The stiff draw did not become the problem I thought it would Rating 6

Flavor and Strength: A bit of sweetness on the lips before lighting. First third, lot of leather on the nose. On a couple of puffs I was getting something sour that I can’t identify. Second third, the sourness still seems to be there, ant the taste moved toward earthy and nuts. I would call this a medium bodied smoke. Last third, the leather is coming back. Putting it down with 1.5 inches left. Rating 4

Overall: I am not a huge fan of box press cigars, just don’t like the way they feel in my mouth. I might be willing to try another one of these to see if the sourness might have been something left on my pallet from lunch. Based of this sample, I don’t think I would have these in my humi. Rating 4

This was later revealed to be a Hoyo De Monterrey Prensado Oscuro
 
Oh hell, i may be a little to late for this one. If not- Im always up for a ginni' pig assessment :ss

Sorry man, I made sure that I had enough for the guys that had responded -- using the last sticks in two boxes. I want to make sure that everyone gets the same sticks out of the same boxes

If this goes over well, I may look to another one in the fall/winter
 
Ok guys - the cigars not being hand delivered went in the mail today:

CALGARY, AB CJ171518860US
FEEDING HILLS MA 0103 8555 7494 4490 8655
FORT COLLINS CO 0103 8555 7494 1345 1373
SAN DIEGO CA 0103 8555 7493 9247 9856
LEXINGTON SC 0103 8555 7493 8199 4094
TUCSON AZ 0103 8555 7494 0296 5614
INDIANAPOLIS IN 0103 8555 7494 2393 7133
BREMERTON WA 0103 8555 7494 3442 2895

Please make sure to let me know when you get them


I'll post the unbanded picture later tonight
 
Ok guys - the cigars not being hand delivered went in the mail today:

CALGARY, AB CJ171518860US
FEEDING HILLS MA 0103 8555 7494 4490 8655
FORT COLLINS CO 0103 8555 7494 1345 1373
SAN DIEGO CA 0103 8555 7493 9247 9856
LEXINGTON SC 0103 8555 7493 8199 4094
TUCSON AZ 0103 8555 7494 0296 5614
INDIANAPOLIS IN 0103 8555 7494 2393 7133
BREMERTON WA 0103 8555 7494 3442 2895

Please make sure to let me know when you get them


I'll post the unbanded picture later tonight

Thank You for the Digits.

James.
 
Here is a snap shot of the sticks you will be receiving - next week (Sunday) I will post a review thread for stick number 1, the next week I will post what the smoke was, and post a thread for stick #2's review, etc.

Remember no guessing what the stick is in the thread (plus I have tried to organize the sticks to confuse) - if you feel the need, send me a PM
 
You guys have nice postal people. As mine is holding out on me!!!! It was processed in Federal Way yesterday and most of the time would have been here today, however I am sure they are holding out on me LOL. Fast FAST shipping. Crazy only mailed out Saturday and has made it to Washington already. One more day. :)
See most of them have been delivered already All right starting to dislike my carrier lol. J/K will be here tomorrow I am sure. the wait is killing me LOL
James.
 
As there have been a couple of questions - Remember, we do have 1 package going through customs heading north. It's going to take a couple of days extra for that shipment.

Feel free to let the cigars rest for a few days

If you are going on vacation, you can send me your review, and I will post it in the proper thread - otherwise you always have 1 full week to post your review before we start hunting you down :D

I will post the first thread on 6/8 (SSSS #1), everyone has until 6/15 to post their review, on that date I will reveal the cigar, and post the next thread (SSSS #2), and so on - if you have some extra free time, and want to get an early start, just save your review on your computer, and post it when the thread gets posted
 
Nice looking Sticks got mine today. Got them resting in my 20ct Hummi by them selfs until testing day. Wish I could start backwards LOL. #5 looks well aged and yummy. :) Thank you for including me in this.

James.
 
Looks like our Canadian player is the only one without the sticks yet - and it's showing as "Status: Into Foreign Customs" - hopefully not too much longer!
 
Back
Top